• image
AWC-Logo-nobg full 01AWC-Logo-whitebg-full 02
American Women's Club of Hamburg

I Do Not Care If We Go Down in History as Barbarians

Radu Jude, Romania | Germany | Bulgaria | France | Czech Republic

Romania filmmaker Radu Jude’s satirically dark docu/drama/comedy, set in modern day Romania, illuminates a little-known chapter of WW II history in which military dictator Ion Antonescu ordered the Romanian troops to massacre between 25,000 and 34,000 Jews following the capture of Odessa, Ukraine, in October 1941. Flippant and chilling words spoken in the Council of Ministers in the summer of 1941 reappear as the title of the film: “I do not care if we go down in history as barbarians.” This was just the beginning of the ethnic cleansing campaign, a precursor to the Holocaust. Before the country switched to the Allies’ side in 1944, Romanians had slaughtered around 380,000 Jews, gypsies and other minorities, a horrifying number second only in ranking to the Germans. (One character cynically remarks to the other, “Why do we always come in second?”)

The film opens in front of the National Military Museum in today’s Bucharest. Theater director Mariana Marin (Ioana Iacob) is planning an elaborate reenactment of the 1941 Odessa Massacre as an outdoor historical pageant in front of the town hall. She spends her days casting actors, directing scenes, and testing weapons and special effects with her crew. In these rather messy, sometimes humorous, and seemingly chaotic sequences it becomes clear that many of the civilian actors/extras and the city officials, represented by Movilă (Alexandru Dabija), reject Romania’s odious political history and want a redacted, sanitized patriotic spectacle to please the public. Stubbornly determined, Mariana sets out to reenact the atrocities of the Odessa Massacre in all its horror.

Played with intelligence, spunk, and beauty Radu Jude has chosen the perfect lead in Ioana Iacob to play Mariana. (Unconventionally, the actress introduces herself as Ioana in the opening sequence, and slips back into Ioana at the end of the film.) Mariana does seem to spend a lot of time in the bath or naked with her married pilot boyfriend (Șerban Pavlu). However Mariana’s true passion is elsewhere; she is consumed with the burning desire to abolish Romanians’ selective memories about the war.

Though much of the film is shot in long, mobile, hand-held takes, Jude also includes old documentary wartime footage. Twice he films archive still photographs of the brutal massacre; everything stops in its tracks for a seemingly long time….long enough for the audience to squirm in their seats looking  at the horrific photos. What should make us squirm even more is watching Mariana and her crew clinically and casually analyzing the quality of the photographs trivializing the subject matter, the corpses.

While the film has its brilliant moments, unfortunately it is heavily weighted down with didactic, intellectual conversations referencing among others Hannah Arendt, Walter Benjamin, Ludwig Wittgenstein, and Karl Marx. Later coming off the intellectual perch they included film directors, Steven Spielberg, Jean-Luc Godard, and Leni Riefenstahl. In one segment Mariana reads aloud from a philosophical essay for what seems like an eternity. (Yawn.) Being a very experienced filmmaker, Jude inevitably must know scholarly debate and erudite readings would not endear the film to the average moviegoer. Still I DO NOT CARE IF WE DO DOWNIN HISTORY AS BARBARIANS had its world premiere in the Karlovy Vary International Film Festival in the Czech Republic and won the main prize, the Crystal Globe, and the non-statutory Europa Cinemas Label Award for best European film.  (PF)

Our Sponsors